Topics Drug Resistance (AMR) Seminar" Held History and Current Status of Countermeasures against Infectious Diseases: Learning from Semmelweis
The "Drug Resistance (AMR) Seminar: Learning from Semmelweis" was co-hosted by the Japan Medical Association and the Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Association of Japan (PMAJ) on November 22, 2019, at the Japan Medical Association Hall (Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo) in conjunction with November, the month for promoting measures against drug resistance (Anti-Microbial Resistance, AMR). Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo). In this seminar, leading experts from industry, academia, and government gave presentations on the history of countermeasures against infectious diseases, the current status of AMR countermeasures in Japan, and the development of new antimicrobial agents. In addition, a panel discussion was held to further promote understanding among the general public, healthcare professionals, and government officials that AMR is an urgent social issue.
The venue
Opening remarks
In his opening remarks, Dr. Yoshitake Yokokura, President of the Japan Medical Association, introduced Semmelweis, who was born in Hungary in 1818, and who recommended the prevention of postpartum fever by encouraging hand washing, which was considered a threat in the mid-19th century. In 2018, a bust of him was installed at the headquarters of the Japanese Red Cross Society to commemorate the bicentennial of his birth. Regarding efforts against drug resistance (AMR), he stated that since Japan's first "Action Plan against Drug Resistance (AMR)" was formulated in 2016, the importance of proper use of antimicrobial agents has been promoted, and the Japan Medical Association has been actively involved in this area.
Japan Medical Association
Dr. Yoshitake Yokokura, Chairman
Lecture 1 History of Infectious Diseases and Current Issues - Learning from Semmelweis' Teachings
President, Japan Health Policy Institute (NPO), Professor Emeritus, National Graduate Institute for Policy Studies (GRIPS)
Kiyoshi Kurokawa
In his lecture, Dr. Kiyoshi Kurokawa, President of the Japan Health Policy Organization and Professor Emeritus of National Graduate Institute for Policy Studies, noted that Semmelweis noted differences in the incidence of postpartum fever between obstetric facilities in the era before the development of bacteriology by Pasteur and others, and the similarity of autopsy findings in patients who died from postpartum fever and other diseases. He also introduced episodes in which he encouraged hand washing with disinfectant after each delivery, noting the similarities between the incidence of postpartum fever among obstetric facilities and pathological autopsy findings in patients who died of other diseases. He also pointed out the significance of learning from Semmelweis' foresight in taking countermeasures based on the hypothesis derived from his observations when infectious diseases caused by bacteria and viruses that had become resistant due to regional and inter-national transmission suddenly became a problem in today's globalized world.
Lecture 2 Various issues surrounding AMR (drug resistance)
Director, International Center for Infectious Diseases, National Center for Global Health and Medicine
Mr. Takao Omagari
Takao Omagari, Director of the International Center for Infectious Diseases, National Center for Global Health and Medicine, presented the various measures that have been taken in Japan in response to the Action Plan for AMR control, as well as their achievements and challenges.
First, he noted that the percentage of residents in Japan who have accurate knowledge about drug resistance and antimicrobial agents is low compared to European countries, and that it is necessary to provide more opportunities for people to be exposed to correct knowledge. In addition, he stated that, in terms of local AMR measures, support for infection control and treatment in small and medium-sized hospitals and elderly care facilities is needed, guidance should be developed, and the network of additional medical institutions for infection prevention measures should be further expanded and their support extended. Regarding the proper use of antimicrobials, he noted that the practice of the common cold has improved over the years, and the antimicrobial prescription rate fell from 60% in 2015 to 30% in 2017, but this is still insufficient, and that overall antimicrobial use fell 10.6% in 2018 compared to 2013 due to the "Guide to Proper Use of Antimicrobials" and other factors On the other hand, the use of injectable drugs increased by 10.0%, which was attributed to the use of injectable drugs for elderly patients over 65 years old. In addition, he pointed out various other issues, such as the introduction of resistant bacteria from overseas, one-health measures, and insufficient supply of antimicrobial agents and stagnation in the development of new antimicrobial agents.
On the other hand, as an achievement, he introduced the establishment of the Joint Common Platform for Infection Control (J-SIPHE). He stated that the actual status of microorganism detection and antimicrobial use at each medical institution has been visualized, and comparisons with other institutions and national data have become possible, making it possible to use this information for countermeasures against resistant bacteria.
He concluded by expressing his view that while the past 15 years have been spent raising awareness of the concept of appropriate use of antimicrobial agents and meeting unmet medical needs through changes in dosage and administration and expansion of indications, the next 10 years will see Japan become a global leader in promoting AMR control together with all stakeholders in society, and contribute to the development of medicine and society. He expressed his view that it is important for Japan to become a global leader and contribute to the development of healthcare and society.
Lecture 3 Efforts of the Japan Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Association in Countermeasures against Infectious Diseases
Akira Kawahara, Executive Director, Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Association of Japan
Akira Kawahara, Executive Director of the Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Association of Japan (PMAJ), began his presentation with an overview of PMAJ and the situation surrounding the pharmaceutical industry, followed by an explanation of PMAJ's efforts to combat infectious diseases, particularly AMR.
In the Action Plan for AMR control, the pharmaceutical industry is expected to make the "appropriate use of anti-microbial agents" and "research and development and drug discovery" in particular, and although it supplies medical facilities with therapeutic agents for various pathogens such as bacteria and viruses, preventive and therapeutic measures are still insufficient for some types of pathogens. However, for some types of pathogens, preventive and therapeutic measures are still inadequate.
He also introduced that the Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Association of Japan (PMAJ) is engaged in various activities to promote and raise awareness of AMR countermeasures through cooperation with domestic academic societies related to infectious diseases, medical associations and other related organizations, the Asian Pharmaceutical Associations Conference (APAC), and the Nikkei Asia-Africa Conference on Infectious Diseases. In addition, the health agenda for the 2019 G20 Osaka Summit includes the development of a sustainable environment for R&D and drug discovery, namely, pull-type incentives (1) Market Entry Reward, (2) Transferable Exclusivity Extension, (3) He also mentioned that the Leaders' Declaration includes the consideration of these incentives.
In closing, Executive Director Kawahara pointed out that there is no trump card for AMR countermeasures and that steady efforts are needed. In particular, as an R&D-oriented pharmaceutical industry, he believes that the most important thing is to introduce pull-type incentives that lead to sustainable research and development of antimicrobial agents as soon as possible, and to have industry-academia-government collaboration to materialize such incentives. He also expressed his determination to move forward while gaining public understanding.
Lecture 4 Various Issues of Infectious Diseases and International Cooperation from the Standpoint of Public Administration
Mr. Satoshi Shimada, Specialist, Tuberculosis and Infectious Diseases Division, Health Bureau, Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare
Satoshi Shimada, Specialist, Tuberculosis and Infectious Diseases Division, Health Bureau, Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare, began his presentation by pointing out that infectious diseases are not only a domestic problem due to the problem of tuberculosis in Japan and the increase in human traffic associated with globalization, and he discussed the need to continue to make antimicrobial agents valuable in the future.
In his speech, Dr. Shimada explained that Japan is now acting on the five pillars of the World Health Organization's Global Action Plan for AMR (awareness-raising, surveillance, infection prevention and control, appropriate use of antimicrobial agents, and promotion of research and development), as well as the Action Plan for AMR control, which includes international cooperation. He also described the results of the plan, including several case studies. For example, in the area of public awareness, he reported on activities to increase public awareness through effective use of collaborations with celebrities and animations, and in the area of surveillance, he reported on the release of a trend survey report summarizing antimicrobial use and outbreaks of resistant strains for the public awareness conference. The report also included a report on the use of antimicrobial agents and the outbreak of resistant bacteria. Furthermore, in the area of infection prevention and control, he mentioned that an additional fee was newly established for hospitals that have an antimicrobial agent proper use support team (AST). As part of the promotion of proper use, he also mentioned that the first edition of the Guide to the Proper Use of Antimicrobial Agents was published in 2017, and that a second edition is now being prepared with additional guidance for infants and young children.
As part of the R&D promotion, he reported on the support for drug discovery and development against drug-resistant bacteria, which are considered important by WHO, through the Health and Labor Sciences Research, the Japan Agency for Medical Research and Development (AMED), and the Global Health Technology Fund (GHIT Fund), among others. In addition to such push-type support, he also mentioned the need for pull-type incentives to support new drugs after their launch, and stated that in order to realize such incentives, the need for new antimicrobial agents and their development must be widely known and understood by the public.
Panel Discussion
Moderator
- Mr. Ryoji Noritake, Director/CEO, Japan Health Policy Organization (JHPO)
- Ms. Kaoru Matsuzawa, Adjunct Fellow and Attorney-at-Law, Japan Health Policy Organization (JHPO)
Panelists
- Dr. Takao Omagari, Director, International Center for Infectious Diseases, National Center for Global Health and Medicine
- Akira Kawahara, Executive Director, Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Association of Japan
- Mr. Satoshi Shimada, Specialist, Tuberculosis and Infectious Diseases Division, Health Bureau, Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare
- Dr. Satoshi Haranuma, Executive Director, Japan Medical Association
- Dr. Satokazu Suzuki, Director, Center for Drug Resistance Research, National Institute of Infectious Diseases
Based on the previous lectures, Dr. Satoshi Kamaharan, Executive Director of the Japan Medical Association, and Dr. Satowa Suzuki, Director of the Center for Drug Resistance Research, National Institute of Infectious Diseases (NIID), joined the newly joined panel to discuss the current status and challenges of domestic efforts to combat AMR, and the role Japan should play in the international community and its future prospects.
Dr. Haramada explained that the "Guide to the Proper Use of Antimicrobial Agents" is highly appreciated as an opportunity to raise awareness of AMR in daily medical practice, and that further educational activities for the public are required. She also reported that the role of the family physician is to ensure that prescribed medications are taken as directed, which is the most important issue in the role of the family physician, and that efforts are being made through the Japan Medical Association Continuing Education System and the Family Physician Skills Training System. As a future prospect, he mentioned the problem of stable supply of antimicrobial agents, which has become an issue in the medical field, and stressed the need for a system to secure truly necessary antimicrobial agents as well as bulk pharmaceuticals.
Executive Director, Japan Medical Association Dr. Satoshi Hamanami
Dr. Suzuki reviewed the relationship between the evolution of surveillance data on resistant bacteria and efforts in the domestic medical field. He also pointed out that the resistance rate of methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA), a typical resistant bacterium, has decreased from 70% in the early 2000s to 47% at present, which is still below the Action Plan's target of 20%. The reason for this decline is the contribution of the additional fee for infectious disease control. He also cited the cases of multidrug-resistant Pseudomonas aeruginosa (MDRP), which has been decreasing remarkably in recent years, vancomycin-resistant enterococci (VRE), and multidrug-resistant Acinetobacter (MDRA), whose resistance rates are controlled at remarkably low levels compared to other countries, and explained that MDRP was successfully reduced by improving methods of handling urine and other materials from hospitalized patients, He introduced the history of MDRP, which was successfully reduced by improving the handling of urine and other materials in hospitalized patients, and MDRA and VRE outbreaks, which were suppressed by thorough understanding of the current situation and nosocomial infection control efforts based on reporting of all cases of MDRA and VRE. He emphasized the importance of controlling resistant bacteria not only in Japan but also overseas, and pointed out that more attention must be paid to nosocomial infection control measures against the increasing number of overseas travelers in the future. Furthermore, from the viewpoint of international contribution, he mentioned the importance of capacity building of bacteriological laboratories in each country in order to solve this problem, as resistant bacteria will soon occur if new drugs are inappropriately used in developing countries where there are many patients with resistant bacterial infections.
National Institute of Infectious Diseases National Institute of Infectious Diseases (NIID)
Dr. Satokazu Suzuki
While Dr. Omagari recognized that certain achievements have been made in the proper use of antimicrobial agents and infection prevention measures, he stated that in terms of public awareness, despite efforts, it is difficult to see the results, and that it is necessary to continue such efforts once again. In addition, he pointed out the necessity of taking a broader perspective in terms of the scope of infectious disease control measures, including outpatient facilities and elderly care facilities, and as a perspective for the future action plan, he pointed out the need to visualize the actual status of infectious diseases in the community and to take a more in-depth look at international measures, such as measures against resistant bacteria overseas, by comparing the list of causative organisms and various guidelines developed by WHO with the situation in Asia and Japan. In response to the WHO's list of causative organisms and various guidelines, Mr. Shimada expressed his belief that there is a separate context for the situation in Asia and Japan, and emphasized the need to disseminate ideas that are appropriate for each environment within the international community as well.
Mr. Shimada commended the project for its achievements in terms of raising awareness and reducing antimicrobial use, and expressed his intention to establish a regional AMR control network in the future. In terms of measures to promote new drug development, he mentioned pull-type incentives as well as push-type incentives, which were shared.
From the standpoint of a pharmaceutical company, Executive Director Kawahara expressed the importance of continuing to provide information on the proper use of drugs, the need for an incentive system that would maintain an environment in which new drugs are continually brought to market as a business, based on the premise of proper use in the medical field, and the expectation that, as a precondition for this, awareness that new drugs are beneficial for society will grow among the public. He also expressed his hope that the public will recognize the benefits of new drugs for society.
In closing, Dr. Omagari stated that although the public has been informed about drug resistance and its proper use, it is necessary for us to make the public aware of the need to reduce the number of drug-resistant bacteria and the burden of seeking new drugs, and that the public needs to understand this, He concluded the panel discussion.
Director/CEO, Japan Health Policy Institute Ryoji Noritake
Adjunct Fellow, Japan Health Care Policy Institute
Attorney at Law
Panel Discussion
Closing Remarks
In his closing remarks, Joji Nakayama, Chairman of the Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Association of Japan (PMAJ), emphasized the importance of continuing to promote partnerships between industry, academia, government, and the private sector to address the AMR problem, with the division of roles between promoting appropriate use in clinical settings, educating patients, and creating new drugs as needed. He also mentioned the importance of continuing to promote partnerships between industry, academia, government, and the private sector. Chairman Nakayama also summarized the outcomes of the seminar, noting the need to regularly share information on the current status of AMR initiatives through opportunities such as this seminar, which brought together stakeholders from industry, academia, government, and the private sector.
Chairman, Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Association of Japan
Summary
Under the AMR Action Plan announced in 2016, various ongoing efforts are being made to combat AMR. In addition, the Leaders' Declaration of the G20 Osaka Summit in June 2019 included a statement calling for an analysis of push and pull incentive mechanisms to identify the best models for research and development of new medicines targeting AMR and report back to relevant G20 ministers. The momentum to strengthen efforts to combat AMR is growing, and the role of R&D-based pharmaceutical companies (e.g., further promotion of appropriate use and development of new AMR drugs) is expected to become increasingly important.
( Yusuke Ariyoshi, Shoji Kawata, Takashi Kuroda, Tomoko Tatebayashi, Hiroyuki Yoshida, Infectious Diseases Group, Global Health Subcommittee, International Committee)
